EMPLOYMENT PRENUPS AND OTHER UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES OF NEW UK LABOUR LAWS

Posted on November 17, 2026

← Back to Info Centre

THE new employee friendly laws introduced this year by the UK government are already causing a ripple effect that could yet influence employment law and practice in the Isle of Man.

The Employment Rights Act 2025 of Parliament reshapes the statutory protection enjoyed by employees with headline changes being a reduction in the standard unfair dismissal qualifying period from two years to six months and removal of a compensation cap for successful unfair dismissal claimants. These phased in changes do not apply in the Isle of Man.

But smart labour lawyers in the UK are already plotting routes to help mitigate the effects of these changes for their employer clients; for instance there is talk of whether an ‘employment prenup’ might actually work in practice. This would be some form of employment settlement agreement that is settled at the start of employment rather than the end. Compromise agreements which waive employee rights are heavily regulated both in the Isle of Man and the UK but in quite different ways. In the UK an employment settlement agreement has a strict statutory gateway that permits waiver of employment rights provided the parties comply with section 203 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 of Parliament, which mandates, amongst other things, that the employee must receive advice from a relevant independent adviser with the employer contributing to the legal fees. In the Isle of Man we still settle employment disputes by an employment settlement agreement conciliated through Manx Industrial Relations Service, we have not adopted the concept of a ‘relevant independent adviser’ as originally introduced in the UK in 1996. Our system continues to work well.

Whether future employment claims can be compromised is already the subject of much UK case law. The latest position is that future claims might be compromised under an employment settlement agreement provided they are clearly identified and waived in a manner compliant with the statutory conditions. The Isle of Man is likely to follow that broad legal principle but with any necessary local adjustments.

UK observers now remark that to mitigate the risk of an uncapped compensation claim resulting from termination of employment, some form of advanced settlement agreement could be reached at the start of the employment relationship, hence the prenup analogy.

An illustration of where this could be useful might involve a high earner such as a Premier League football manager. They are routinely dismissed with no regard for the fair and reasonable procedure required by employment protection legislation. Hitherto in the UK that has hardly mattered financially because of the compensation cap on Tribunal claims which, in the context of crazy football money, is relatively small. The removal of the compensation cap means managers or players might be advised to make a statutory unfair dismissal claim in the light of their multimillion-pound packages.

But what if on signing up they had made an employment prenup limiting their unfair dismissal entitlement in the event of a termination. This method would have to comply with the statutory gateways for contracting out of employment rights (the 1996 Act in England or the MIRS conciliation route in the Isle of Man). If it did, then it might have a chance of being upheld particularly if it was limited to ordinary unfair dismissal, not seeking to compromise all future statutory claims. The current law deals with when future claims are settled on termination of employment, it does not contemplate an agreement made before employment starts. Until tested in the Courts therefore this route will remain untried but nonetheless an interesting possibility.

A further angle being explored by concerned employers might be to sign up for legal expense insurance. In the UK there are plenty of such providers but they are also available on island. Businesses can insure the risk of employment claims which also will enable access to legal advice helplines. Manx businesses should beware obtaining UK legal expense insurance as we are a different legal jurisdiction and English solicitors are unlikely to be qualified (and may not be insured) to advise on Isle of Man employment law. A legal expense insurance policy for Manx businesses or individuals must cover Manx advocate advice and not be restricted to UK legal advice.

Yet another consequence of the UK changes was explained by our associate advocate Lizzie Beard in her article here Probationary Periods - A Pointless Exercise? - MP Legal which noted that probationary periods are themselves looking rather redundant in the UK with the pending reduction of the unfair dismissal qualifying period to six months, that often being the length of a probationary period anyway.

The Isle of Man has long adopted a wait and see attitude before emulating significant changes to its employment protection legislation, this approach being cognisant of the differing pressures and requirements of a much smaller jurisdiction. A good example of this has been our consistent unfair dismissal qualifying period of one year whereas the UK in comparison has chopped and changed depending on the politics of the government in power at the time. It is not inconceivable that the six month UK qualifying period will be reversed if a centre right party is next elected.

Consistent with its measured approach, no doubt the Isle of Man will keep an eye on all labour law developments in the UK particularly as it is already clear the significant changes may themselves invoke the law of unintended consequences. Meantime Manchester United’s legal team may well be casting an eye towards employment prenups.

John Aycock is head of M&P Legal’s employment team with 35 years’ experience of labour law in three jurisdictions. This article is not legal advice, please take advice on the facts of each case.

Back to top